They Stopped for a School Bus. The Driver Behind Them Was on a Phone.

Cars stopped behind a school bus with its stop arm out on a rural Indiana highway

On Tuesday afternoon, a line of cars stopped on US 231 in rural Tippecanoe County while a school bus let children off. Then a pickup truck kept coming. Police say the driver was distracted by a cellphone. Five cars were wrecked, one woman died, and two people were flown to Indianapolis hospitals. It’s exactly the kind of crash the Indiana hands-free law was written to prevent.

Our thoughts are with her family and with everyone who was hurt. At Keller & Keller, we’ve helped injured Hoosiers since 1936, and we see what distracted driving does to families every week. Here’s what happened, what Indiana law says about phones behind the wheel, and what you can do if a distracted driver hits you.

What Happened on US 231 Near Romney

The crash was reported around 4 p.m. on Tuesday, November 17, on southbound US 231 near Bennett Road. That’s just south of Romney and about 15 miles south of Lafayette, according to WTHR. Traffic had stopped behind a school bus that was unloading children. Thankfully, the bus itself wasn’t hit.

According to the Tippecanoe County Sheriff’s Office, the driver of a Ford F-350 failed to stop and struck the back of a Hyundai carrying three adults. As a result, the Hyundai was pushed into a chain-reaction crash with three other cars. The Hyundai’s rear passenger, a woman believed to be in her 50s, died at the scene. Meanwhile, the other two people in that car were flown to Indianapolis hospitals with life-threatening injuries.

A preliminary investigation indicated the pickup driver was distracted by a cellphone. Police don’t believe drugs or alcohol played a role, although toxicology results are still pending. The sheriff’s Crash Reconstruction Team is still investigating, so some details may change.

What the Indiana Hands-Free Law Says

Since July 1, 2020, the Indiana hands-free law has made it illegal to hold a phone or other mobile device while you drive. You can still talk through Bluetooth or a headset. You can also follow GPS directions, as long as the phone isn’t in your hand. However, texting, scrolling, or dialing with the phone in your hand is off-limits.

A violation is a Class C infraction with a fine of up to $500. In addition, since July 2021, the BMV adds points to your driving record for a hands-free violation. Collect enough points in a short time, and you could lose your license.

Even so, the habit is hard to break. According to the Indiana Criminal Justice Institute, police wrote 18,887 hands-free citations in 2024. That was a record high and the third straight yearly increase, up from 14,957 the year before.

Why a Few Seconds Behind the Wheel Matter

INDOT says a driver who reads or sends a text takes their eyes off the road for about five seconds. At 55 mph, NHTSA says, that’s like driving the length of a football field with your eyes closed.

On a rural highway like US 231, traffic doesn’t usually stop, so drivers don’t expect it to. But a school bus, a tractor, or a car waiting to turn left can bring a whole line of cars to a halt. If the driver behind is looking down, there may be no time to brake at all. Plus, a heavy pickup like an F-350 hits with far more force than a small car.

The numbers show how common this is. Nationwide, NHTSA reports that 3,208 people were killed in crashes involving distracted drivers in 2024. Here at home, state officials say distracted driving and speeding together caused more than 17,000 crashes and 230 deaths in Indiana in 2024.

School Bus Stops and Rear-End Crashes

Indiana law requires drivers to stop when a school bus has its stop arm out and its red lights flashing. Most of us know that rule. What fewer drivers think about is the danger coming up behind them while they wait.

Stop-arm violations are still common, too. During a one-day count in April 2026, Indiana school bus drivers reported 1,042 vehicles illegally passing their stopped buses, according to the Indiana Department of Education. That works out to more than 187,000 illegal passes over a full school year.

When you’re stopped behind a school bus, these habits can help:

  • Leave at least a car length in front of you, so you have room if you’re pushed forward
  • Glance at your rearview mirror, especially on fast rural highways
  • Tap your brakes as you slow down, so drivers behind you notice sooner
  • Keep your own phone on Do Not Disturb While Driving and out of reach
  • Watch for children crossing in front of and behind the bus

Hit by a Distracted Driver? The Indiana Hands-Free Law and Your Rights

Indiana is a fault state. So when a distracted driver causes a crash, that driver and their insurance company should pay for your medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering. In fact, breaking the Indiana hands-free law can be strong evidence that a driver was careless.

Passengers have rights, too. If you were riding in a car that got hit, you can usually make a claim against the at-fault driver. When a crash takes a life, the family may have a wrongful death claim. And if the distracted driver was working at the time, the employer may also be responsible.

Evidence can disappear quickly, though. Phone records, vehicle data, and school bus camera video may all help prove what happened. That’s why an attorney will often send letters asking that this evidence be saved. Insurers also tend to shift blame, so it helps to know how disputing fault after a car accident in Indiana works. Finally, you generally have two years to file an Indiana car accident claim.

How Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers Can Help in Lafayette and Across Indiana

Our team helps people hurt in car accidents in Tippecanoe County and throughout Indiana. Your first consultation is free, and we can meet at your home, at the hospital, or virtually. With our Zero Fee Guarantee, you don’t pay attorney fees unless we win. Your focus should be on recovery.

If you or someone you love was hurt by a distracted driver, call us at (317) 926-1111. And the next time your phone buzzes while you drive, let it wait. Following the Indiana hands-free law could save a life.

This post is for general information only and isn’t legal advice. Crash details come from WTHR and the Tippecanoe County Sheriff’s Office and may change as the investigation continues. Citation figures come from the Indiana Criminal Justice Institute, stop-arm figures come from the Indiana Department of Education, and national figures come from NHTSA.

Add Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers as a preferred source

Choose us in your Google preferred sources so our updates are easier to find when you search.

Zero Fee Guarantee

You Pay Us Nothing* Until a Recovery is Made on Your Behalf

Get Started Now

*Clients may owe court costs if they lose.

Indianapolis, IN 
Office

2850 N Meridian St
Indianapolis, IN 46208

(317) 926-1111

South Bend, IN 
Office

16658 Cleveland Road
Granger, IN 46530

(574) 277-7773

Anderson, IN 
Office

902 Main St Ste 210 Anderson, IN 46016

(765) 746-7566