Indiana Negligent Security Lawyers
Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers’ Winning Approach
Free Case EvaluationInjured by Negligent Security?
Get started with a free case evaluation. No Fee Until We Win.
100% Free Evaluation
Provide a few details and our team will handle the rest.
"*" indicates required fields
“As a busy mom of three, I’m so grateful I didn’t have to face the legal battle alone. Thank you, Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers.”
Kelly
When you’ve been the victim of a violent crime on someone else’s property, you need more than sympathy. You need a battle-tested sword and shield fighting for your rights.
Keller & Keller has been maximizing client settlements and delivering justice since 1936, establishing our firm as one of Indiana’s leading premises liability law firms. With over 90 years of experience holding negligent property owners accountable, we’ve recovered millions of dollars for our clients, proving that results matter when you’re seeking an Indiana negligent security lawyer.
Our Indianapolis negligent security lawyers understand that being attacked in a place where you expected to feel safe can change your life in an instant. Physical injuries, emotional trauma, and financial stress pile up while property owners and their insurance companies try to avoid responsibility. This is when having an experienced Indiana negligent security lawyer matters.
Why You Need a Negligent Security Lawyer After an Attack
The aftermath of a violent crime can turn your life upside down. You’re dealing with physical injuries, emotional trauma, and mounting medical bills while trying to understand how this happened in a place that should have been safe.
Navigating Complex Legal Claims
Understanding Insurance Company Tactics
Understanding Statute of Limitations
What to Do After Being Attacked on Someone’s Property
Taking the right steps after a violent crime can protect both your health and your legal claim.
See What Your Case Is WorthGet to a safe location and call 911 immediately
Go to the emergency room even if injuries seem minor
File a police report documenting every detail you remember
Take photos of the location, broken locks, poor lighting, or lack of security
Get contact details from anyone who saw what happened or the conditions
Keep all medical records, police reports, and incident documentation
Document broken cameras, unlit areas, non-functioning locks, or absent security
Early legal representation helps preserve evidence and build your case
The Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers Approach:
Indiana Injury Lawyers Who Fight to Win
From the moment you contact us, you’ll notice the difference in our approach. Our client-first philosophy means we take the time to understand not just the details of your accident but how it has affected your life, your work, your family, and your future in Indiana. We clearly communicate every step of the process in plain language you can understand, no confusing legal jargon. This approach has earned us countless 5-star reviews from real Indiana clients who’ve experienced the Keller & Keller difference firsthand.
We understand that being injured in an accident is stressful enough without having to chase down your lawyer for updates. That’s why we’ve built our practice around transparent, consistent communication.
When you hire us, you’ll have direct access to the Indiana-based attorney handling your case as well as a dedicated paralegal who monitors its daily status. We keep you informed throughout every stage of your claim, explaining what’s happening, what to expect next, and how it affects your case.
Our 90+ years of experience isn’t just about longevity. It’s about results. Our attorneys have successfully handled thousands of cases in Indiana and recovered thousands of millions of dollars for our clients. We’ve gone toe-to-toe with the biggest insurance companies and won. Our courtroom experience means we’re always prepared to take your case to trial if that’s what it takes to secure fair compensation. This willingness to fight, and our track record of success, often motivates insurance companies to offer better settlements to avoid facing us in court.
The Negligent Security Claim Process with Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers
When you choose Keller & Keller to handle your Indiana negligent security claim, you can expect a clear, structured process designed to maximize your compensation.
Types of Negligent Security Cases We Handle In Indiana
Our extensive experience covers all types of negligent security incidents throughout Indiana.
Hotel and motel attacks are assaults in hotels with broken locks, non-functioning room security, or inadequate monitoring of hallways and parking areas. A traveler depends on the property for the door, the key system and the lighting outside the room. Indiana law doesn’t make a hotel answerable for every crime on its grounds, so these claims turn on what the hotel knew and what was happening before the attack.
Can a Hotel Owe a Duty to Protect You From a Crime?
An owner owes an invitee the highest premises duty, which is reasonable care for that person’s protection while on the property (Burrell v. Meads, 569 N.E.2d 637 (Ind. 1991)). A registered guest will usually fit that category. That general duty doesn’t settle a crime case, though. When a third party’s crime causes the injury, the court decides as a matter of law whether it was foreseeable, looking at the broad type of plaintiff and harm rather than the case’s specific facts (Goodwin v. Yeakle’s Sports Bar & Grill, Inc., 62 N.E.3d 384 (Ind. 2016)).
A judge may therefore decide the question before a jury ever hears the case. In one 2018 decision, the Court of Appeals held that a resort hotel owed a guest no duty as a matter of law to protect her from a criminal attack on its premises (Cosgray v. French Lick Resort & Casino, 102 N.E.3d 895 (Ind. Ct. App. 2018)). That is a single decision on its own facts, not a rule that hotels never owe a duty. Our Indiana premises liability guide explains how visitor status works.
Why a Broken Lock Is Not Just a Detail
Indiana’s foreseeability analysis varies depending on whether a case involves a dangerous condition on the premises or a dangerous activity there (Pennington v. Memorial Hospital of South Bend, Inc., 223 N.E.3d 1086 (Ind. 2024)). A failed lock is a physical condition, while an assault is someone’s act. The two sides may disagree about which analysis fits, and the way the facts are presented can matter.
Facts Specific to Lodging
- Door hardware. Maintenance tickets may show that a lock, latch or connecting door was reported as failing and left unrepaired.
- Key control. Electronic locks can keep a record of which card opened a door and when. Lost master keys or active cards for former staff may also come up.
- Same-night warnings. A call to the front desk about someone trying doors or following a guest may matter more than an old incident report.
- Hallways and lots. Exterior corridors and rear lots can be hard to see from the desk. Camera coverage, lighting and overnight staffing show what the property was actually watching.
- Who runs the property. The brand on the sign may not own or operate the building, so management agreements can matter.
Many of these records are held by the hotel and may be overwritten in the ordinary course of business. If an attack took a life, see our Indiana wrongful death page.
Apartment complex violence means attacks in apartment buildings with poor lighting, broken entry systems, or failure to screen residents. Tenants and their guests depend on the landlord for the shared spaces they can’t fix themselves, such as gates, stairwells and parking areas. These claims are measured against Indiana’s general foreseeability framework, so being hurt at home doesn’t by itself create a case against the owner.
Who Controls the Space Where It Happened?
A landlord’s duty generally follows control. A multi-unit landlord answers for the common areas it keeps, but a single-family landlord who has handed over possession generally does not (Olds v. Noel, 857 N.E.2d 1041 (Ind. Ct. App. 2006)). Lease terms can change the result. An attack in a shared hallway therefore raises a different question from one inside a rented house.
Indiana’s landlord statute also requires a landlord to keep common areas clean and proper and to maintain listed systems, such as electrical systems and elevators, in good and safe working condition if they were provided at the start of the rental (Ind. Code § 32-31-8-5). Whether a failure on that list has any bearing on a later crime is a separate question, and it depends on the facts.
What Was Management Told, and When?
The most useful evidence in an apartment case is often a record of what management knew before the attack. A tenant may sue to enforce a landlord’s obligations after giving notice and allowing a reasonable time to repair (Ind. Code § 32-31-8-6). That remedy is about repairs, not crime, but written notice has a second value: it can show that an office knew a door wouldn’t lock or a walkway had gone dark.
- Repair requests. Work orders and portal messages can date a broken gate or a failed buzzer, and show how long it stayed that way.
- Specific threats. A report that a neighbor threatened someone, or that a former partner was getting in, may mean more than general complaints about the area.
- Lease violations. Notices to a tenant about fights or harassment can show what management knew about a particular person.
- Vendor records. Courtesy patrol reports, camera contracts and lighting invoices can show what was promised and what was done.
The Harder Question of Screening
Some claims argue that a complex should never have rented to the person who committed the attack. The evidence usually starts with the application, any background check and the company’s own written policy. It then moves to what staff actually learned about that resident before the attack, and whether they acted on it.
A screening theory still has to clear the same duty question as any other claim here, so a court may look closely at it early in the case. For broader background on owners’ obligations, see our guide to Indiana premises liability. If a resident or guest was killed, our wrongful death page explains how those claims work.
Robberies or attacks in poorly lit, unmonitored parking facilities without security patrols are the usual pattern in a parking lot or garage assault claim. They tend to happen when someone is alone and walking to a car, and the attacker is often gone within seconds. A person hurt this way may have a claim against the party controlling the space, but the fault picture is rarely simple.
When the Attacker Is Part of the Fault Picture
A property owner sued over an assault will often point to the attacker. Indiana allows a nonparty defense, which lets a defendant assert that a nonparty caused the damages in full or in part (Ind. Code § 34-51-2-14). A nonparty is someone who caused or contributed to the injury but hasn’t been joined as a defendant (Ind. Code § 34-6-2.1-133). The defendant must plead that defense and carries the burden of proof on it (Ind. Code § 34-51-2-15).
The practical effect can be large. A defendant generally pays only its own percentage of fault, and you can’t collect a nonparty’s share unless that person is sued (Davidson v. State, 211 N.E.3d 914 (Ind. 2023)). A jury that places most of the blame on a robber can sharply shrink what the lot’s owner must pay. How this plays out when the attacker was never identified depends on the facts.
A criminal conviction can help on paper. In an intentional tort, a plaintiff may recover 100% of compensatory damages from a defendant convicted after a prosecution based on the same evidence (Ind. Code § 34-51-2-10). Whether that person can pay is another matter. Our post on how comparative negligence works walks through how fault is divided.
Lot, Ramp or Shared Space: Who Is Responsible?
Parking is often shared, which makes control the first thing to pin down. A strip center’s lot may be managed by a landlord, a garage may be run by an operator under contract, and a hospital or office tower may hire a separate vendor. Leases and management agreements usually show who handled lights, cameras and patrols. A publicly owned garage brings different rules, so see our guide to the Indiana Tort Claims Act.
Lights, Cameras and Patrols as Evidence
- Lighting. Outage reports, repair invoices and a nighttime photo taken soon after the attack can show how dark the area really was.
- Cameras. Some cameras are dummies, broken or aimed elsewhere. Footage from nearby businesses may catch what the lot’s own system missed.
- Patrols. Guard tour logs and vendor contracts can show how often anyone walked the floors and whether promised rounds took place.
- Stairwells and blind corners. Layout can matter, including places where someone can wait out of sight.
These facts generally matter once a court finds a duty exists. For falls and other physical hazards, see our post on parking garages and premises liability.
Shopping center incidents are crimes at retail locations with inadequate security, often where people knew of criminal activity in the area. In Indiana, though, a neighborhood’s reputation or a list of earlier crimes usually won’t carry a claim by itself. What matters most is what the business knew about the danger building at that moment.
Why Past Crime Isn’t Enough on Its Own
The Indiana Supreme Court addressed this directly in 2020. For a sudden criminal attack, a business’s duty depends on whether it knew or had reason to know of a present and specific circumstance making imminent harm likely, and past incidents at the location do not alone create a duty (Cavanaugh’s Sports Bar & Eatery, Ltd. v. Porterfield, 140 N.E.3d 837 (Ind. 2020)). In plain terms, that means a stack of old police reports may not be enough. The decision reversed a Court of Appeals opinion that had relied on a history of reported incidents.
Retail cases show how hard this can be. In a sudden store shooting, the Court of Appeals held that a grocery had no duty to protect a customer, either before or after the shooting began (Godfread v. Martin’s Super Markets, L.L.C., 120 N.E.3d 234 (Ind. Ct. App. 2019)).
The Greenwood Park Mall Litigation
Not every case ends there. In the Greenwood Park Mall shooting case, the Court of Appeals let the claims against the mall owner and security company go past a motion to dismiss (Simon Property Group, Inc. v. Stewart, No. 24A-CT-1700 (Ind. Ct. App. June 9, 2025)). That is an early, pleadings-stage ruling. It isn’t a finding of duty on the evidence or a finding of liability, so it shows only that such a claim can survive the first stage.
What Can Set One Case Apart From Another
Since general crime history has limited force, attention shifts to the hours and minutes before the attack. Facts that may help distinguish a claim include:
- A live warning. A threat, a dispute or a suspicious person reported to staff or security before the attack.
- A situation staff could see. An argument that kept escalating, or a group staff had already asked to leave.
- What security did next. Whether a guard or manager responded, called police or walked away.
- Who held responsibility. The center’s owner usually controls the common areas, while each tenant runs its own store. A lease or a security contract can show who was supposed to do what.
Incident logs, radio traffic and security reports for that day may matter most. Video can tell you when a confrontation started and whether anyone saw it, and those recordings may not last long. Our Indiana premises liability guide explains how owners and visitors are treated more generally. If the injury came from a hazard rather than a crime, see our slip and fall page.
Violent incidents at establishments that over-serve alcohol without proper security staff are the focus of a bar or restaurant attack claim. They may involve a patron who turns on another customer, a fight in the doorway or a confrontation that spills into the lot. Indiana courts draw a sharp line here between violence that erupts without warning and trouble that staff could see coming.
Sudden Attack or a Fight That Was Building?
The leading case went against the injured patron. The Indiana Supreme Court held that a sudden shooting of one patron by another in a neighborhood bar was not foreseeable as a matter of law, so the bar owed no duty to prevent it (Goodwin, 62 N.E.3d 384 (Ind. 2016)). The court also said it declined to impose a duty that would approach strict liability.
That isn’t blanket immunity. The Court of Appeals found a duty at a restaurant whose staff knew of rising tension before a shooting (Hamilton v. Steak ’n Shake Operations, Inc., 92 N.E.3d 1166 (Ind. Ct. App. 2018)). It reached a similar result after staff were warned of an earlier altercation between two groups (BoJak’s Bar & Grille v. Henry, 170 N.E.3d 264 (Ind. Ct. App. 2021)). In another case, a bar wasn’t entitled to judgment of no duty where a patron ejected for fighting promptly punched a man outside the entrance (Buddy & Pals III, Inc. v. Falaschetti, 118 N.E.3d 38 (Ind. Ct. App. 2019)). These rulings dealt with duty only, so breach and causation still had to be proved.
Over-Serving Is a Separate Legal Question
Serving too many drinks doesn’t automatically make a bar liable for what a customer does next. Under the Dram Shop Act, a person who furnishes alcohol isn’t civilly liable for damages caused by the recipient’s impairment unless the furnisher had actual knowledge the recipient was visibly intoxicated when served, and the intoxication was a proximate cause (Ind. Code § 7.1-5-10-15.5). Both elements are needed. The Act modified but did not eliminate common-law negligence claims, and such a claim must still satisfy its requirements (WEOC, Inc. v. Adair, 226 N.E.3d 771 (Ind. 2024)).
Dividing Fault Between the Business and the Attacker
If a case reaches a jury, it allocates fault between the business and the attackers, and that allocation gets great deference (Paragon Family Restaurant v. Bartolini, 799 N.E.2d 1048 (Ind. 2003)). Your own conduct can count as well. If you started the fight, for example, your share may reduce your recovery, and you are barred if your fault is more than 50% (Ind. Code § 34-51-2-6). Our post on comparative negligence in Indiana explains that rule.
The proof tends to be specific to the night. Tabs and point-of-sale records can show what was served and when, and video may show how the customer looked. Staff messages and incident logs can reveal who was warned. Our guide to Indiana premises liability offers more background, and our wrongful death page applies if someone was killed.
An attack at a business that failed to implement basic security measures for employees is the usual starting point for a workplace violence claim. An employee may be assaulted by a coworker, a customer, a stranger or someone from home. Indiana’s worker’s compensation system often controls the claim against your own employer, so a security case at work usually looks beyond the employer.
What Worker’s Compensation Does to a Security Claim
Rights and remedies under the Worker’s Compensation Act generally exclude all others against an employer for an injury covered by it (Ind. Code § 22-3-2-6). An injury inflicted by a coworker or attacker at work can fall within the Act when it is by accident and arises out of and in the course of employment (Evans v. Yankeetown Dock Corp., 491 N.E.2d 969 (Ind. 1986)). The test depends on the facts, and “arising out of” means caused by employment-related risks.
This cuts both ways. Benefits may be available without proving anyone was careless, but weak security alone generally won’t open the door to an injury lawsuit against your employer. An exception exists for an injury the employer itself intended, and nothing short of deliberate intent or actual knowledge that an injury is certain to occur will do (Baker v. Westinghouse Electric Corp., 637 N.E.2d 1271 (Ind. 1994)). A coworker’s intent isn’t automatically the employer’s.
Who Else Could Be Responsible?
When someone other than the employer or a co-employee is legally liable, you or your dependents may sue that person even though compensation is paid or payable (Ind. Code § 22-3-2-13). In a security case, that could mean the owner of the building, a property manager, or a contracted guard company. These third-party claims still have to meet Indiana’s duty requirements for crimes on a property, so each one needs its own look.
If you take compensation, the employer or carrier has a lien on any settlement, award or judgment from the third party. A coworker who attacks you isn’t always protected, either. A co-employee is immune only if the act arose out of and in the course of both workers’ mutual employment (Wine-Settergren v. Lamey, 716 N.E.2d 381 (Ind. 1999)). Our post on when you need an attorney after a workplace accident explains how compensation and third-party claims can run side by side.
When an Attack Comes From Outside the Job
Some assaults have nothing to do with the work itself, such as an abusive former partner who shows up at the front desk. Whether that injury is tied to employment-related risks can decide which system applies, so the reason for the attack may be a central fact.
- Earlier reports. Emails to a supervisor or human resources about a threat or a stalker.
- Access records. Badge logs, visitor sign-ins and door alarms from that day.
- Building agreements. Leases and security contracts that show who controlled entrances and guards.
- Safety complaints. An Indiana occupational safety complaint may document concerns, but that chapter does not create any private right of action (Ind. Code § 22-8-1.1-48.3).
If an employee died, see our wrongful death page for general information about those claims, keeping in mind that worker’s compensation rules may also apply.
ATM robberies are assaults at ATM locations without adequate lighting, surveillance, or security presence. Someone standing at a machine with cash in hand, often after dark, is an easy target. These machines also sit in very different places, including bank vestibules, drive-up lanes, gas stations and the outer walls of stores, and that placement shapes who might be responsible.
Who Answers for the Ground Around the Machine?
The name on the screen may tell you little about who controls the space. A bank may own the machine and the building. A separate operator may own the ATM while a store or landlord controls the lot, the lights and the sidewalk. Indiana’s premises duties depend on a visitor’s status as an invitee, a licensee or a trespasser (Burrell v. Meads, 569 N.E.2d 637 (Ind. 1991)), and on who actually owns or occupies the property.
That is why placement agreements and leases can matter as much as the police report. They may show who agreed to maintain lighting, who owned the camera, and who was supposed to fix what. Our guide to Indiana premises liability covers the general rules for property owners.
Would Better Security Have Stopped It?
A robbery at a machine is often the kind of sudden attack where Indiana asks about a present and specific circumstance, so earlier robberies at that spot may not be enough alone. Duty isn’t the only hurdle. Even with a duty, you still have to show the owner failed to use reasonable care and that this failure helped cause your injury.
That last step is proximate cause, and it can be a real fight in ATM cases. The defense may say a determined robber would have struck anyway, with or without another light or camera. The broader totality-of-the-circumstances test no longer governs duty, but Indiana’s Supreme Court has said it remains useful for foreseeability in proximate cause (Goodwin, 62 N.E.3d 384 (Ind. 2016)). This is where facts about the site itself may count:
- Sight lines. Whether shrubs, walls or signs hid the machine from the street.
- Lighting. Whether the area around the machine was lit well enough for you to see someone approaching.
- Camera placement. Whether a working camera could see the approach or only the keypad.
- Location choices. Whether the machine was tucked behind a building or sat in the open.
Your Transaction Record as a Time Stamp
ATM cases come with an unusually exact clock. Your bank record can show the machine, the date and the minute of the transaction, and that can help locate the right footage from the ATM and from cameras nearby. It may also help match a stolen card’s later use to the same person.
Video from these sources may be recorded over quickly, so a police report and a prompt request can make a difference. Light outages, service tickets and complaints from other customers may also be available from the bank or property owner. If a robbery turned fatal, see our Indiana wrongful death page.
Attacks on educational properties with insufficient access controls or security personnel can take place in a hallway, a dorm, a stadium lot or a parking structure. The first thing to establish is who runs the school, because public and private institutions can follow very different rules in Indiana.
Public School, State University or Private Campus?
| Type of school | How Indiana treats it |
|---|---|
| Public school corporation | A political subdivision under the Indiana Tort Claims Act. Notice is generally due within 180 days after the loss (Ind. Code § 34-13-3-8). |
| State educational institution | Also a political subdivision, despite the word “state” in the name, so the 180-day notice applies rather than the 270-day state period (Ind. Code § 34-6-2.1-155). |
| Charter school | A governmental entity for the Tort Claims Act (Ind. Code § 34-6-2.1-77). Which notice period applies should be confirmed early. |
| Private school or college | Not on the political subdivision list, so the Tort Claims Act’s notice rules may not apply. |
Timing is unusually pressing here, because the notice period can run out long before the general limit on suing. Our guide to Indiana school injury claims walks through that notice.
What Changes When the Defendant Is Public
- A harsher fault rule. The Comparative Fault Act doesn’t apply to government defendants, so the more-than-50% rule isn’t the test. Even slight fault by the injured person can bar recovery (Funston v. School Town of Munster, 849 N.E.2d 595 (Ind. 2006)).
- A presumption for younger children. Where contributory negligence applies, children aged 7 to 14 are presumed incapable of it, though that can be rebutted (Clay City Consolidated School Corp. v. Timberman, 918 N.E.2d 292 (Ind. 2009)).
- Limits on money. Combined liability of governmental entities and employees generally can’t exceed $700,000 per person and $5,000,000 per occurrence (Ind. Code § 34-13-3-4). Punitive damages aren’t available against them.
- Listed immunities. The Act includes immunity for the act or omission of anyone other than the governmental entity or its employee (Ind. Code § 34-13-3-3). How that applies to an attack depends on the facts, and it may be a central issue in a case where an outsider did the harm.
- One lawsuit. A person suing both government and private defendants over one injury must sue them all together (Davidson v. State, 211 N.E.3d 914 (Ind. 2023)). That matters if a private security contractor was involved.
Proof That Fits a School or Campus
Whatever the school, the same broad foreseeability analysis generally shapes the duty question. Evidence often comes from the systems a school uses to control who gets in. Door logs, visitor check-in records, ID card data and camera coverage can show how an attacker reached the victim.
Earlier reports may matter more when they are specific. A threat passed along to a teacher, a resident assistant’s note about a particular person or a campus police record can show what staff knew and when they knew it. Our guide to the Indiana Tort Claims Act explains how a claim against a public body proceeds.
Entertainment venue violence means assaults at concerts, theaters, or events with inadequate crowd control or security. Large events mix alcohol, close quarters and rivalries, and a fight can start in seconds. Unlike a corner store, an event is planned in advance, so there is often a paper trail showing how the organizers thought about safety.
Planned Event, Unplanned Violence
Indiana’s framework for activities on land asks whether the broad type of plaintiff and harm was foreseeable (Rogers v. Martin, 63 N.E.3d 316 (Ind. 2016)). Courts make that call as a matter of law, so a venue can win before a jury hears the details. A sold-out show doesn’t automatically mean an assault was foreseeable in that sense.
Live information can change things. If ushers or guards saw a confrontation heating up in the stands and did nothing, the claim looks more like the escalating-trouble cases than a sudden attack. Those decisions came from restaurants and bars, so how far they reach a concert depends on the facts.
Rogers offers another angle, this one about what happens after the first injury. The homeowner there had no duty to prevent an unforeseeable fistfight, but could owe a duty to protect a guest from a foreseeable worsening of his injury once she found him hurt. Whether that idea helps at a venue depends on the circumstances, but a slow medical response or a crowd left to block first aid may be worth a close look.
Several Companies Behind One Night
One event can involve a building owner, a promoter, a ticketing firm, a beverage vendor and an outside security contractor. Who controlled the entrance, the floor and the exits is usually spelled out in contracts. Each can point at the others, and that matters because the jury enters a verdict against each defendant for its own percentage of fault (Ind. Code § 34-51-2-8). A company left out of the suit may leave part of the loss uncollected.
A venue owned by a city, county or state university may bring in government notice rules and a different fault standard. Festivals held on public land can raise the same issue, so ownership should be checked early. See our guide to the Indiana Tort Claims Act.
Records That Show How the Event Was Run
- The security plan. Staffing numbers, guard posts, and how the event was expected to be run.
- Crowd and entry data. Ticket scans, capacity figures and any changes to bag checks or entrances.
- Radio and dispatch logs. These can show when a problem was first reported and how long a response took.
- Incident reports and video. Venues often log ejections and fights, and cameras may show whether staff were at their posts.
Our post on concert and festival injuries discusses overcrowding and other event hazards. For background on what owners owe visitors, see our Indiana premises liability guide.
Attacks in healthcare facilities with insufficient security in emergency rooms or psychiatric units can injure staff, visitors and other patients alike. Patients in crisis, anxious families and long waits all come together in these settings. Who was injured, and by whom, can change the entire legal route.
A Security Claim May Turn Into a Malpractice Claim
Calling something premises liability doesn’t make it so. In one case, a claim that a psychiatric group home failed to protect a resident from another resident was dismissed as falling under the Medical Malpractice Act rather than ordinary premises liability (Martinez v. Oaklawn Psychiatric Center, Inc., 128 N.E.3d 549 (Ind. Ct. App. 2019)). The court affirmed dismissal for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. That is one Court of Appeals decision, but it shows that healthcare settings may route through the Act.
That route has real consequences. A qualified provider’s case generally goes to a medical review panel first, and the damages limits and act-based time limit described on our Indiana medical malpractice page may apply. Filing under the wrong framework can cost valuable time.
Your Role in the Building Matters
- Patients. A decision about observation, room placement or restraint may be treated as health care, particularly on a psychiatric unit. If so, the Act may control.
- Visitors. A visitor attacked in a waiting room or a parking ramp isn’t receiving care. Those claims are more likely to be analyzed under ordinary premises and foreseeability rules, depending on the facts.
- Staff. Nurses and aides hurt at work generally look first to worker’s compensation, and our discussion of workplace violence above explains why claims against an employer are limited.
- People hurt by a guard. If hospital security staff caused the harm directly, different questions arise about who employed the guard and what that person was doing.
Public Hospitals, Warning Signs and Missing Video
Hospitals run by a city or county count as political subdivisions (Ind. Code § 34-6-2.1-155). That can bring in Tort Claims Act notice within 180 days and a harsher fault rule, explained in our Indiana Tort Claims Act guide. Knowing who owns a hospital is therefore one of the first things to find out, since a name alone may not tell you.
As in other sudden-attack cases, specific warning signs can matter. A patient who had threatened someone that shift, a flagged behavioral alert or a request for help that went unanswered may say more than a general history of incidents. Observation logs, staffing records and security dispatch notes can show what staff knew and what they did.
Hospital video can be fragile evidence. In a 2026 decision, the Indiana Supreme Court affirmed a trial court’s refusal of a spoliation instruction over unsaved hospital video, and noted it has not decided whether mere negligence justifies an adverse-inference instruction (Rosen v. Community Healthcare System, No. 25S-CT-217 (Ind. Mar. 11, 2026)). Asking early that footage be kept may matter, because a court may not make up for its loss later.
The Hard Truth
Indiana Negligent Security Statistics That Demand Action
When we talk about negligent security in Indiana, we’re addressing real violence that happens when property owners cut corners on safety. As your advocates, you deserve to know the sobering facts behind our mission.
That marks the fifth consecutive year exceeding 200 deaths. The city’s violent crime rate of 1,028 per 100,000 residents is 178% higher than the national average, with residents facing a 1 in 95 chance of becoming a victim of violent crime. This violence crisis demonstrates why property owners must implement adequate security measures in parking lots, apartment complexes, hotels, and commercial properties.
Many violent crimes occur in locations where adequate security could have prevented the attack. Parking lots, apartment complexes, hotels, and commercial properties remain high-risk areas where owners often cut costs on security guards, lighting, surveillance, and access controls rather than prioritizing safety.
Behind every statistic is a human story, victims facing devastating medical expenses, long-term psychological treatment, lost wages, and permanent trauma. Crime costs an estimated $618 per household in 2025. Property owners who fail to provide adequate security must be held accountable for the harm their negligence causes.
Leading Security Failures That Lead to Attacks
Understanding what went wrong helps establish the property owner’s liability.
Negligent Security Injuries We Represent In Indiana
Violent crimes on negligently secured properties cause devastating physical and emotional injuries.
At Keller & Keller, we work with both medical experts and mental health professionals to fully document all your injuries, ensuring your compensation reflects not just your current condition, but the long-term impact this attack will have on your life.
Compensation Available for Indiana Negligent Security Victims
If you’ve been injured in a violent crime due to negligent security on someone else’s property, you may be entitled to various types of compensation.
Economic Damages
These are quantifiable financial losses, including:
- Medical expenses (past, current, and future treatment)
- Lost wages and reduced earning capacity
- Psychological counseling and therapy costs
- Rehabilitation and long-term mental health treatment
- Security system expenses for your home
- Relocation costs if you can no longer feel safe in your residence
Non-Economic Damages
These more subjective damages compensate for:
- Pain and suffering from physical injuries
- Emotional distress and psychological trauma
- Loss of enjoyment of life and sense of security
- Disfigurement and scarring from assault
- Loss of consortium (impact on marital and family relationships)
- Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and ongoing anxiety
Punitive Damages
In cases involving particularly egregious negligence, such as property owners who ignored repeated criminal incidents or deliberately disabled security systems to cut costs, Indiana courts may award punitive damages designed to punish the wrongdoer and deter similar behavior.
Wrongful Death Damages
When negligent security incidents result in fatalities, surviving family members may recover compensation for funeral and burial expenses, loss of financial support and benefits, loss of companionship and guidance, and the pain and suffering of their loved one before death.
How Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers Investigates Indiana Negligent Security Cases
Our meticulous approach to evidence gathering builds the strongest possible foundation for your claim:
Setting the Indiana Standard
Cutting-Edge Investigation Technology
While other law firms rely on outdated methods, Keller & Keller leverages cutting-edge technology to build stronger cases and win bigger settlements for our Indiana negligent security clients.
Professional drone documentation
Captures property layouts from angles impossible with traditional methods, providing evidence of inadequate lighting, security blind spots, broken fencing, overgrown landscaping that provides criminal hiding places, and overall security deficiencies across large properties like apartment complexes and parking lots
Advanced voice-over-IP networks
Enables real-time collaboration between attorneys, investigators, security experts, and witness interviews, ensuring no detail is overlooked in documenting the property owner’s negligence
Digital forensics and data recovery
Our technicians retrieve evidence including deleted surveillance footage, security system logs showing when cameras or alarms were disabled, electronic access records, and maintenance requests that prove the property owner knew about security failures
Cloud-based case management
Provides you 24/7 access to your case information and status updates, allowing you to track progress while focusing on your physical and emotional recovery
Rapid-response investigation
Allow us to conduct on-site evidence gathering within hours of an incident, preserving evidence like lighting conditions at the time of day the attack occurred, witness statements before people relocate, and physical evidence before the property owner can make repairs to cover up negligence
Service Areas
Indiana Cities We Serve
What Sets Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers Apart
With so many law firms advertising their services, why choose Keller & Keller? The differences are clear.
No Fee Until We Win!
Get Started TodayDon’t Take Our Word For It!
View More Testimonials“By far exceeded our expectations”
JoAnne
From the moment we reached out to Keller & Keller to the case settling in less than 5 months Amanda guided us step by step, what to expect when, she was very thorough. We are extremely grateful for her superb service. I would highly recommend the firm.
“I was very pleased with the legal services I received from Keller & Keller”
Kevin
The time after my car accident was very frustrating. During the most hard times, I always turned to my paralegal, and they would listen. I was very happy with the outcome of my case and would recommend Keller & Keller to anyone in need of an outstanding personal injury law firm!
Take Action Now
Your Indiana Negligent Security Claim Starts Here
Free Consultation
We’ll evaluate your case honestly and explain your options in plain English. We’ll come to you, whether you’re at home, in the hospital, or wherever is convenient.
We Fight
Our experienced team fights to investigate thoroughly, deal with insurance companies, and handle all the legal complexities while you focus on getting better.
You Recover
Focus on healing while we handle the rest. We’ll fight for you like we’d fight for our own family, because that’s exactly how we see you.
Zero Fee Guarantee
We believe everyone deserves quality legal representation, regardless of their financial situation. That’s why we work on a contingency basis. You pay absolutely nothing unless and until we win your case. No upfront costs, no hidden fees, no financial risk to you.
* Clients may owe court costs if they lose
The Keller Tradition:
Three Generations of Fighting for Indiana Families
Frequently Asked Questions
Have questions about your case? We’re here to help.
Injured and not sure what to do next?
We’ll help guide you through everything you need to know