Indiana Medical Malpractice Lawyer
Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers’ Winning Approach
Free Case EvaluationInjured by Medical Negligence?
Get started with a free case evaluation. No Fee Until We Win.
100% Free Evaluation
Provide a few details and our team will handle the rest.
"*" indicates required fields
“As a busy mom of three, I’m so grateful I didn’t have to face the legal battle alone. Thank you, Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers.”
Kelly
When you’ve been hurt by medical negligence, you need more than just any lawyer. You need a battle-tested sword and shield fighting for your rights.
At Keller & Keller, we’ve been maximizing client settlements and delivering justice since 1936, establishing our firm as one of Indiana’s leading medical malpractice law firms. With over 90 years of experience taking on hospitals, doctors, and insurance companies, we’ve recovered millions of dollars for our clients. That’s not just a number. That’s thousands of families we’ve helped get their lives back on track after medical errors turned their world upside down.
Why You Need an Indiana Medical Malpractice Lawyer After Medical Negligence
The aftermath of medical malpractice can devastate your life and your family’s future. Medical bills continue mounting while you’re dealing with worsened health conditions, and the very professionals you trusted have failed you. But here’s the truth, hospitals and medical institutions are already working to protect themselves from liability.
Navigating Complex Legal Claims
Understanding Insurance Company Tactics
Understanding Statute of Limitations
What to Do After Medical Malpractice
The steps you take immediately after discovering medical negligence can protect both your health and your legal rights.
See What Your Case Is WorthSee another healthcare provider immediately to address complications from the negligence
Get copies of all records related to your treatment from every provider involved
Keep detailed notes about your symptoms, conversations with medical staff, and how the negligence has affected your life
Preserve medical bills, prescription records, and any correspondence with healthcare providers
Avoid detailed conversations about negligence with the medical providers involved
Don’t sign any releases or settlements without legal representation
Have another qualified doctor evaluate your condition and treatment
The sooner we start investigating, the better we can preserve
The Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers Approach:
Indiana Injury Lawyers Who Fight to Win
From the moment you contact us, you’ll notice the difference in our approach. Our client-first philosophy means we take the time to understand not just the details of your accident but how it has affected your life, your work, your family, and your future in Indiana. We clearly communicate every step of the process in plain language you can understand, no confusing legal jargon. This approach has earned us countless 5-star reviews from real Indiana clients who’ve experienced the Keller & Keller difference firsthand.
We understand that being injured in an accident is stressful enough without having to chase down your lawyer for updates. That’s why we’ve built our practice around transparent, consistent communication.
When you hire us, you’ll have direct access to the Indiana-based attorney handling your case as well as a dedicated paralegal who monitors its daily status. We keep you informed throughout every stage of your claim, explaining what’s happening, what to expect next, and how it affects your case.
Our 90+ years of experience isn’t just about longevity. It’s about results. Our attorneys have successfully handled thousands of cases in Indiana and recovered thousands of millions of dollars for our clients. We’ve gone toe-to-toe with the biggest insurance companies and won. Our courtroom experience means we’re always prepared to take your case to trial if that’s what it takes to secure fair compensation. This willingness to fight, and our track record of success, often motivates insurance companies to offer better settlements to avoid facing us in court.
The Medical Malpractice Claim Process with Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers
When you hire us for your Indiana medical malpractice case, we don’t waste time. Our investigation starts immediately because medical evidence can disappear quickly.
Types of Medical Malpractice We Handle
Our extensive experience covers all types of medical negligence throughout Indiana, each presenting unique challenges and requiring specialized legal knowledge.
Wrong-site surgery, forgotten surgical instruments, anesthesia mistakes, and post-operative complications from negligent care all count as surgical errors. The common thread is a preventable mistake before, during or after an operation. A poor result alone doesn’t prove one, because every operation carries risks that can occur even with careful work.
When the Mistake Speaks for Itself
Indiana malpractice plaintiffs generally need expert testimony on the standard of care, meaning what a reasonably careful provider would have done. There is an exception for matters within a layperson’s common knowledge, such as a surgical object left in a patient (Simms v. Schweikher, 651 N.E.2d 348 (Ind. Ct. App. 1995)). A jury may not need a surgeon to explain why a sponge shouldn’t stay behind after the incision closes.
Res ipsa loquitur, a Latin phrase for an event that suggests negligence by its nature, can also replace expert testimony in limited circumstances (Gold v. Ishak, 720 N.E.2d 1175 (Ind. Ct. App. 1999)). Its use has typically been limited to surgical implements and other foreign objects, though it isn’t strictly confined there. Don’t assume it will carry a case with nothing left behind. In one Indiana appeal, a trial court that excused expert testimony was reversed (Narducci v. Tedrow, 736 N.E.2d 1288 (Ind. Ct. App. 2000)).
Operating Room Errors That Usually Call for a Medical Expert
- Wrong-site surgery. The team operates on the wrong body part, the wrong side or even the wrong patient. These cases often focus on the consent form, the skin marking and the pause to confirm details before the first incision.
- Anesthesia mistakes. Examples include a dosing error, a missed allergy, or a lapse in watching breathing and oxygen levels. The anesthesia record can show what was given and what the monitors displayed, often minute by minute.
- Post-operative complications. Bleeding, a clot or a bowel injury can become far more dangerous when no one responds to the warning signs. Indiana’s definition of malpractice reaches care that should have been provided as well as care that was (Ind. Code § 34-18-2-18), so a failure to check on a patient can matter as much as a slip of the scalpel.
Who Was in the Room, and What Was Written Down
An operation involves a surgeon, an anesthesia provider, nurses, technicians and usually a hospital or surgery center. The Medical Malpractice Act’s definition of a health care provider includes physicians, hospitals and nurses, plus officers, employees or agents acting in the course of employment (Ind. Code § 34-18-2-14). Each person’s role can differ, so the records have to show who did what.
The most useful documents are often the operative report, the anesthesia record, nursing notes and the instrument and sponge counts taken before closing. Imaging may show a retained object, and a later surgeon’s notes may describe what had to be repaired. Our post on what can go wrong in the operating room covers more examples. If an implant or surgical tool failed rather than the team, see our Indiana defective drug and device page.
Failure to diagnose covers cancer misdiagnosis, heart attack misdiagnosis, stroke misdiagnosis, and other conditions where delayed diagnosis worsens outcomes. The harm is usually lost time: an illness that could have been treated sooner keeps advancing while you are told nothing serious is wrong. A wrong first impression isn’t automatically negligence, so these cases ask what a careful provider would have done with the same symptoms and test results.
What the Records Often Show in a Missed Diagnosis
- Cancer. A suspicious scan or biopsy gets no follow-up, a lump is dismissed as harmless, or a symptom such as rectal bleeding is blamed on something minor. Records of tumor size and stage over time can help show what the delay changed.
- Heart attack. A patient with chest pain, jaw pain or shortness of breath is told it’s anxiety or heartburn. The questions often include whether an electrocardiogram and blood tests were done, and whether they were repeated.
- Stroke. Sudden weakness, slurred speech or confusion may be written off as a migraine, intoxication or fatigue. Some stroke treatments work only within a limited window, so the timing of each decision can matter.
- Other serious conditions. Sepsis, blood clots in the lung and appendicitis can each look like something milder early on.
Doctors are trained to list the conditions that could explain a patient’s symptoms, then rule out the most dangerous ones. A chart that shows no such thinking, or a test that was never ordered, can become the center of the case. Referrals, portal messages and phone notes may also show whether a concern ever reached the right person.
Why the Date of the Missed Visit Matters
Indiana’s malpractice clock generally starts on the date of the alleged act, omission or neglect, not the day you learn of it (Ind. Code § 34-18-7-1). A missed diagnosis can stay hidden, which makes this rule hard on patients. The limit can’t constitutionally bar someone who could not reasonably have discovered the malpractice in the two years (Martin v. Richey, 711 N.E.2d 1273 (Ind. 1999); Van Dusen v. Stotts, 712 N.E.2d 491 (Ind. 1999)). Someone who discovers it too late in that period must file within a reasonable time (Booth v. Wiley, 839 N.E.2d 1168 (Ind. 2005)), so these exceptions are narrow and depend on the facts.
A Lost Chance, Not Just a Bad Outcome
The defense in these cases often argues that the disease would have taken the same course no matter when it was found. Indiana handles a negligently reduced chance of survival through section 323 of the Restatement of Torts, with no separate loss-of-chance doctrine (Mayhue v. Sparkman, 653 N.E.2d 1384 (Ind. 1995)). In plain terms, that means a reduced chance of survival can be considered, but it is analyzed under an existing rule rather than as its own claim. Doctors’ testimony about the patient’s odds at the time of the missed visit may become central.
Before a lawsuit, a claim against a qualified provider generally goes to Indiana’s medical review panel, where other health care providers review the records. If a delayed diagnosis ended in a death, see our Indiana wrongful death page.
Birth injury cases involve cerebral palsy from oxygen deprivation, Erb’s palsy from delivery complications, and other preventable birth trauma. The harm happens during pregnancy, labor or delivery, and it can shape the rest of a child’s life. Not every birth injury comes from negligence, because some conditions have causes unrelated to the care given. The question is whether the medical team missed warning signs or acted too slowly.
How Decisions in the Delivery Room Can Injure a Baby
- Oxygen deprivation. Fetal heart monitoring can signal that a baby is in distress. A delayed response, including a delayed cesarean delivery, can leave the brain without enough oxygen. Our post on cerebral palsy as a birth injury explains how that condition can follow.
- Erb’s palsy. When a baby’s shoulder lodges behind the mother’s pelvic bone during delivery, too much force on the head and neck can stretch or tear the nerves running to the arm.
- Forceps and vacuum injuries. Improper use of these tools may cause skull fractures or bleeding inside the head.
- Unmanaged pregnancy conditions. High blood pressure, gestational diabetes or infection can put a baby at risk when left unaddressed.
These cases often rest on fetal monitor strips, nursing notes, prenatal records, Apgar scores, placental pathology and newborn brain imaging. Experts may use them to separate a preventable injury from a genetic or infectious cause. Obstetricians, nurse midwives, labor nurses and the hospital may each have played a part.
A Young Child’s Claim Has Its Own Timing Rule
Parents often assume a child has until adulthood to bring a claim. Under the Medical Malpractice Act, the two-year period generally applies regardless of minority, except that a minor under six has until the eighth birthday to file (Ind. Code § 34-18-7-1). A child aged six or older gets no minority extension. That matters here because some birth-related conditions aren’t identified until a child misses milestones.
When Care Will Last a Lifetime
A birth injury can require therapy, equipment, home modifications and attendant care for decades. Against a qualified provider, the total recoverable for an injury or death of a patient may not exceed $1,800,000 for an act of malpractice after June 30, 2019 (Ind. Code § 34-18-14-3). Lower limits apply to earlier acts, and the date of the act controls rather than the filing date.
For those later acts, a qualified provider is not liable for more than $500,000. Amounts above that, within the limit, are paid from the patient’s compensation fund. The Act’s definition of “patient” also reaches relatives claiming loss of services or expenses (Ind. Code § 34-18-2-22). A provider who never qualified is outside these limits, and our guide to the Indiana malpractice cap explains how qualification affects a claim. A careful life care plan can show the real cost of a child’s needs, even where a limit applies.
Medication errors include wrong prescriptions, incorrect dosages, dangerous drug interactions, and pharmacy dispensing mistakes. A drug order passes through several sets of hands before it reaches you, and a mistake can enter at any step. The harm may be sudden, as with an overdose or allergic reaction, or it may build slowly as a wrong dose affects the kidneys, liver or heart.
Tracing Where the Order Went Wrong
Because so many people touch a prescription, the first job is usually to find the step where it failed. Each stage tends to leave its own paper or electronic trail.
| Stage | What can go wrong | Records that may show it |
|---|---|---|
| Prescribing | Wrong drug, a dose not adjusted for weight or kidney function, or a known allergy overlooked | Chart, electronic prescribing history |
| Dispensing | A look-alike or sound-alike drug, the wrong strength, or an interaction alert overridden | Pharmacy profile, label, the filled bottle |
| Administering | Wrong patient, wrong time, or a pump set incorrectly | Medication administration record, pump logs, bar-code scans |
| Monitoring | Blood levels never checked for a drug that needs close watching | Lab orders, progress notes |
What Wasn’t Done Can Count as Much as What Was
Medication cases are often about omissions. Indiana defines malpractice as a tort or breach of contract based on health care or professional services that were provided, or that should have been provided, by a health care provider to a patient (Ind. Code § 34-18-2-18). In practice, a doctor who never reviewed your drug list or never ordered follow-up blood work may be as much at issue as one who wrote the wrong number.
Dangerous interactions show how this can play out. Several providers may each prescribe something reasonable alone, while no one looks at the full list. Discharge from a hospital is a common weak point, since home medications and new ones must be reconciled in a short time. Our post on prescription and medication mistakes gives more examples.
Careless Care, or a Dangerous Drug?
A malpractice claim looks at how a drug was chosen, given or watched. If the drug itself was defective or its warnings fell short, see our defective drug and device page. The two can overlap, so the facts need sorting early.
Pharmacies raise their own question. Whether a particular pharmacy or pharmacist is covered by the Medical Malpractice Act should be checked rather than assumed, because the answer can change the procedure a claim must follow. Hospital and clinic staff are often easier to place, though each employer’s status still matters.
The physical evidence can be simple. The original bottle, the label and any remaining pills may show exactly what you received, which is why the bottle shouldn’t be thrown away. A list of what you took and when, along with any symptoms you noticed, can help a reviewing physician connect the drug to the injury.
Emergency room negligence involves failure to properly triage, misdiagnosis in urgent situations, and inadequate treatment of serious conditions. Emergency staff work quickly, often without a patient’s history, and that pressure is part of the picture. The fair question is what a reasonably careful emergency team would have done with what it could see at the time.
Where Emergency Care Tends to Break Down
- Triage. A nurse sorts arriving patients by urgency. A serious complaint scored as routine can leave someone in the waiting room while the condition worsens.
- No reassessment. A patient who waits for hours may get sicker. Records may show whether anyone checked vital signs again.
- A rushed discharge. Abnormal results may still be pending, or a patient may be sent home with instructions that don’t fit the problem.
- A missing consult or transfer. Some conditions call for a surgeon, a neurologist or a hospital with more resources. Delay in making that call may be the real failure.
Electronic charts stamp nearly everything with a time. Triage notes, order times, nursing reassessments and monitor data can show how long a patient actually waited, and which provider saw what. That timeline often does more than anyone’s memory of a chaotic night.
What If Your Own Actions Brought You There?
Many ER patients worry that a crash they caused, or a delay in coming in, will sink their claim. Indiana’s Comparative Fault Act doesn’t apply to a malpractice action against a qualified health care provider (Ind. Code § 34-51-2-1), so the more-than-50% rule used in most injury cases doesn’t control here. Contributory negligence, an older and harsher defense, remains available instead.
There is an important limit. A patient’s conduct before treatment that merely brought her to the doctor isn’t contributory negligence (Cavens v. Zaberdac, 849 N.E.2d 526 (Ind. 2006)). To bar recovery, the patient’s negligence must be simultaneous with the doctor’s fault and unite with it. The defense may therefore focus on what happened during the care itself, depending on the facts.
Whose Emergency Department Is It?
The name over the door doesn’t always tell you who employs the staff. An ER physician may work for an outside group, while the nurses work for the hospital. Each may have a different status under the Medical Malpractice Act.
Ownership can matter too. A city or county hospital is a political subdivision (Ind. Code § 34-6-2.1-155), a claim against one is generally barred unless notice is filed within 180 days after the loss occurs (Ind. Code § 34-13-3-8), and a malpractice claim may engage both statutes. Our guide to the Indiana Tort Claims Act explains that notice. At a Veterans Affairs hospital, the Federal Tort Claims Act remedy is exclusive for malpractice claims against VA health care employees acting within their duties (38 U.S.C. § 7316(a)(1)). If a patient died after being sent home, see our wrongful death page.
Nursing home abuse, in the malpractice setting, means neglect, medication errors, falls, and inadequate care in long-term facilities throughout Indiana. Residents rely on staff for food, medicine, movement and hygiene, so a lapse in care can cause harm fast. When the harm comes from how care was given, the claim may fall under the Medical Malpractice Act. Our Indiana nursing home abuse page covers abuse and neglect more fully.
When a Nursing Home Counts as a Health Care Provider
The Act lists a “health facility” as a health care provider, and that term means a facility licensed under IC 16-28 (Ind. Code § 34-18-2-15). So a licensed nursing home can come under the Act if it is qualified, and a resident’s negligent-care claim may then go through the Act and the patient’s compensation fund (Indiana Patient’s Compensation Fund v. Holcomb, 17 N.E.3d 255 (Ind. 2014)).
Don’t assume every facility is covered. Qualification depends on each provider’s own registration, and a home may not be qualified (Hayes v. Westminster Village North, 953 N.E.2d 114 (Ind. Ct. App. 2011)). Checking a facility’s status is an early step, because it can decide which rules apply.
What Changes if the Act Applies
- Time may run from the neglect. Under the Act, the two years generally run from the alleged act, omission or neglect, not from the day a family noticed the problem (Ind. Code § 34-18-7-1). The period also applies regardless of legal disability, so a resident’s dementia may not extend it.
- A panel comes first. Unless an exception applies, the claim generally goes to a medical review panel before any court action can proceed.
- Damages are limited. The limits for qualified providers, including $1,800,000 for acts after June 30, 2019, can apply to a qualified home.
- Other injuries may be handled differently. When the Act doesn’t reach a claim, other limitation rules may apply, depending on the facts.
Care Failure or Something Else?
Labels don’t settle which rules apply. Indiana courts look at substance, and the Act covers conduct curative or salutary in a provider’s professional capacity, not conduct unrelated to promoting a patient’s health or to professional skill (Howard Regional Health System v. Gordon, 952 N.E.2d 182 (Ind. 2011)). A missed medication or an unassisted transfer looks like health care. A deliberate assault by a staff member may raise different questions, and the answer can turn on the details.
Federal rules can help frame what good care required. A facility must give each resident adequate supervision and assistance devices to prevent accidents (42 CFR 483.25(d)), and residents must be free of any significant medication errors (42 CFR 483.45(f)). The care plan, fall-risk assessments and medication records may show whether staff followed through. Wounds can tell a story as well, as our post on identifying bedsores explains.
Radiology errors involve misread X-rays, CT scans, MRIs, and other imaging studies that led to missed diagnoses. A radiologist may overlook a finding, misjudge what it means, or report it in a way that never reaches the doctor who needs it. Because the images are stored, another physician can later look at exactly what the first reader saw, which sets these cases apart.
How an Image Gets Missed
- The finding goes unnoticed. A small nodule or subtle fracture is visible on the image but isn’t mentioned in the report.
- The finding is misjudged. The radiologist sees something and calls it harmless when it called for more testing.
- There is no comparison. Earlier images could have shown that a spot had grown, but no one looked at them.
- The study was wrong for the question. The scan was done without contrast, cut off the relevant area or came out too blurred to read.
- The result never landed. A critical finding or a recommendation for follow-up imaging sits in a report no one acts on.
Hindsight and the Second Read
Expect the defense to say a finding only looks obvious once you know where to look. A later scan may show a large tumor, and a reviewer going back to the earlier film will naturally find it. The stronger evidence is often an opinion on what a reasonably careful radiologist should have reported from that image at that time.
The original image files matter more than the written report, since a reviewer needs the full study and not a summary. Addenda, time stamps and messages between the radiologist and the ordering doctor can show whether a warning was ever passed along. Radiologists often work for a separate group or read remotely, so the person who missed the finding may never have met you. The ordering doctor’s follow-up can also become part of the case.
How a Review Panel Would Look at the Film
Except as the statutes allow, a court action against a provider can’t begin until the proposed complaint has gone to a medical review panel and an opinion is given (Ind. Code § 34-18-8-4). The panel has one attorney and three health care providers, and the attorney chairs but doesn’t vote (Ind. Code § 34-18-10-3). It must give its opinion within 180 days after the last member of the initial panel is selected (Ind. Code § 34-18-10-13), though replacing a member can add time.
The panel doesn’t award money. It gives a written expert opinion on whether the evidence supports that the provider failed the standard of care, whether a material fact issue exists, or whether the conduct was a factor in the damages (Ind. Code § 34-18-10-22). That opinion is admissible in a later lawsuit but isn’t conclusive, and either side may call a panel member as a witness (Ind. Code § 34-18-10-23). These steps apply to qualified providers, which is why a provider’s qualified status is worth confirming early.
Laboratory errors involve incorrect test results, contaminated samples, and delayed reporting that affected treatment decisions. Doctors lean heavily on lab numbers, so one bad result can steer the whole course of care. Many of these mistakes happen outside the testing machine, in the handling of the sample or the handling of the answer.
From the Needle to the Report
- Collection and labeling. A tube or tissue sample carries the wrong name, so one patient receives another’s result.
- Handling and transport. A specimen is contaminated, left too long or stored at the wrong temperature before it is tested.
- Testing. A machine isn’t properly calibrated, or a technologist runs the wrong test.
- Pathology review. A pathologist misreads a biopsy slide, calling cancer benign or a harmless growth malignant.
- Reporting. A dangerously abnormal value is never called to the care team, or an amended result never reaches the chart.
A Bad Result Can Hurt You Either Way
A false normal can mean no treatment at all, and a serious illness keeps moving while everyone feels reassured. A false positive does a different kind of damage. Patients have undergone unnecessary surgery, chemotherapy or strong medication because a report said something that wasn’t true. Each direction calls for different proof of harm, so the first task is working out what treatment would have been without the error.
Delay is its own failure. A correct result that arrives after a treatment decision has been made may do little good. Time stamps on collection, receipt, testing and reporting can show where the hours went, and call logs can show whether anyone tried to reach the doctor. Sample tracking records, quality-control logs and retained slides may also matter, since a retest of the original tissue can sometimes settle what the sample really showed.
Is the Lab a Qualified Provider?
Labs come in different forms. One may be a department inside a hospital, while another may be an independent company that receives samples from many offices. That difference can matter, because being a listed provider is not the same as being qualified.
To qualify, a provider or its insurer must file proof of financial responsibility with the commissioner and pay the surcharge (Ind. Code § 34-18-3-2). A provider who fails to qualify is not covered and is subject to liability under the law without regard to the Act (Ind. Code § 34-18-3-1). The review panel, damages limits and patient’s compensation fund apply to qualified providers, as our guide to the Indiana malpractice cap explains.
One lab mistake can involve a phlebotomist, a hospital, an outside lab and the ordering doctor, and they may not all share the same status. The fault rules can differ as well, since the Comparative Fault Act’s malpractice exclusion reaches only qualified providers (Ind. Code § 34-51-2-1). If a test kit or analyzer itself was faulty, see our defective drug and device page.
Hospital infection cases involve preventable infections caused by unsanitary conditions or failure to follow proper protocols. Infections can occur even with good care, so catching one in a hospital doesn’t by itself prove negligence. The real questions are how the germ reached you, whether precautions were skipped, and how quickly staff noticed and responded.
Where Preventable Infections Often Begin
- Surgical sites. Problems with sterile technique, instrument sterilization or wound care may let bacteria into an incision.
- Central lines and urinary catheters. Poor insertion technique, or leaving a line in longer than needed, can open a direct path into the body.
- Ventilators. Patients on breathing machines may develop pneumonia when basic prevention steps slip.
- Hands, rooms and isolation. Missed hand hygiene, poor cleaning or a failure to isolate a contagious patient can spread an organism from bed to bed.
- Slow recognition. Fever, redness or confusion may go unaddressed until the infection becomes sepsis. A late response can be a separate failure, even if the infection itself couldn’t have been avoided.
Proving Where the Infection Came From
Causation is usually the hardest part. Infections have many possible sources, so hospitals often argue that the germ came from the patient’s own skin or from a health condition. Timing helps here, along with culture results that identify the organism and records of other patients with the same one. Because these questions are technical, a case will generally need expert testimony on the standard of care.
Much of the proof sits with the hospital, including infection-control records, sterilization and cleaning logs, and staff training materials. If those records go missing, Indiana does not recognize a separate tort for first-party spoliation; the remedy is in the case itself, such as an inference (Gribben v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 824 N.E.2d 349 (Ind. 2005)). The Indiana Supreme Court has not decided whether mere negligence justifies an adverse-inference instruction (Rosen v. Community Healthcare System, No. 25S-CT-217 (Ind. Mar. 11, 2026)). Our post on spoliation in Indiana malpractice cases explains the idea.
Malpractice Claim or Something Else?
An unclean room can sound like an ordinary property problem. Indiana looks at the substance of the claim instead of its label, and the Medical Malpractice Act reaches conduct within a provider’s professional capacity that promotes a patient’s health (Howard Regional Health System v. Gordon, 952 N.E.2d 182 (Ind. 2011)). Skipped protocols during treatment will often look like health care. A claim may be split, too: in one case a breach-of-duty claim fell under the Act while an emotional distress claim over staff insults did not (Terry v. Community Health Network, Inc., 17 N.E.3d 389 (Ind. Ct. App. 2014)).
The route matters, since it can decide whether a review panel comes first. For infections that developed in long-term care, see our nursing home abuse page.
Dental malpractice involves nerve damage, improper procedures, and infections from substandard dental care. Dentists are listed as health care providers in Indiana’s Medical Malpractice Act (Ind. Code § 34-18-2-14), so a claim against a qualified dentist generally follows the same rules as one against a doctor. Much dental work happens in a private office, which can leave fewer eyes on a procedure than a hospital would have.
Common Ways Dental Care Causes Lasting Harm
- Nerve damage. Nerves near the lower jaw can be injured during wisdom tooth removal, implant placement or injections. A patient may be left with numbness, tingling or pain in the lip, chin or tongue.
- Improper procedures. Pulling the wrong tooth, placing an implant in the wrong position or leaving a broken instrument in a root canal can all call for corrective work.
- Infections. An abscess that is ignored, or a procedure done without proper sterile practice, can spread into the jaw, the neck or the bloodstream.
- Office sedation. Sedating a patient without proper monitoring can be dangerous, particularly for someone with a heart or breathing condition.
When a Smaller Claim Can Take a Different Path
Not every dental injury is catastrophic, and the Act has a route for modest claims. A patient may sue without a panel by declaring that the damages sought are not greater than $15,000, and is then barred from recovering more (Ind. Code § 34-18-8-6). That can be simpler, but it trades away anything above that figure.
The statute offers a safety valve. If injuries prove more serious, the patient may seek dismissal without prejudice within two years of commencing the suit and restart through the panel. That matters with nerve injuries, where it can take a long time to learn whether feeling will return. Separately, a claimant may go directly to court if the claimant and all named defendants agree in writing not to use a panel (Ind. Code § 34-18-8-5). For larger claims, our guide to the Indiana medical review panel describes the usual route.
Records a Dental Case Often Turns On
Dental records can be thin compared with hospital charts, so each piece counts. X-rays taken before and after a procedure may show how close a drill or implant came to a nerve, or which tooth was treated. The treatment plan and consent form can show what you were told, and follow-up notes can show whether complaints of numbness or swelling were taken seriously.
A second dentist or oral surgeon’s notes can be just as useful, because they may describe what had to be repaired and why. Those records can also document the cost of bone grafts, implants or further surgery. Responsibility may rest with the dentist who treated you, with a hygienist or assistant acting in the course of employment, or with a practice that owns several offices. Each one’s status matters, so our malpractice cap guide is a useful starting point on qualification.
The Hard Truth
Indiana Medical Malpractice Statistics That Demand Action
The numbers tell a sobering story about medical errors in Indiana, and here’s what gets us fired up to fight for victims.
Indiana hospitals reported 134 serious medical events in 2018, the highest in the state’s reporting history, with 38% of hospitals experiencing at least one reportable error. The most common errors included preventable pressure ulcers (47 events), retained surgical instruments (35 events), and fatal patient falls (21 events). These aren’t just statistics. They’re Indiana families whose lives were changed forever by preventable mistakes.
Medical errors are now the third leading cause of death nationally, behind only heart disease and cancer. Diagnostic errors alone affect 12 million Americans annually in outpatient settings, with approximately 795,000 Americans dying or becoming permanently disabled each year due to diagnostic mistakes. In Indiana, diagnostic errors are the leading cause of medical liability claims.
Indiana’s Medical Malpractice Act caps total damages at $1.8 million per case, with individual healthcare providers liable for up to $500,000 and the remaining $1.3 million covered by the Patient’s Compensation Fund. The Fund pays out approximately $100 million annually in excess damages to victims across the state, money that represents real families dealing with catastrophic injuries from medical negligence.
Leading Causes of Medical Malpractice in Indiana
Most medical errors are preventable, which makes these cases particularly frustrating. Understanding these causes helps us build stronger cases for our clients.
Medical Malpractice Injuries We Represent
Medical negligence doesn’t cause minor inconveniences. It causes catastrophic, life-changing injuries that devastate families and destroy financial security.
Compensation Available for Indiana Medical Malpractice Victims
If you’ve been injured by medical negligence in Indiana, you may be entitled to various types of compensation under the state’s Medical Malpractice Act.
Economic Damages
These are quantifiable financial losses, including:
- Medical expenses (past, current, and future treatment costs)
- Lost wages and reduced earning capacity
- Additional medical care needed due to the malpractice
- Rehabilitation and therapy costs
- Home modification expenses for disabilities
- In-home care and nursing costs
Non-Economic Damages
These more subjective damages compensate for:
- Pain and suffering
- Emotional distress and mental anguish
- Loss of enjoyment of life
- Disfigurement and scarring
- Loss of consortium (impact on marital relationship)
Punitive Damages
In rare cases involving extreme recklessness or intentional misconduct by healthcare providers, Indiana courts may award punitive damages designed to punish the wrongdoer and deter similar behavior.
Wrongful Death Damages
When medical malpractice results in death, surviving family members may recover compensation for funeral expenses, loss of financial support, loss of companionship, and the pain and suffering of their loved one before death.
How Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers Investigates Indiana Medical Malpractice Cases
Our meticulous approach to medical evidence builds the strongest possible foundation for your claim
Setting the Indiana Standard
Cutting-Edge Investigation Technology
While other law firms rely on outdated methods, Keller & Keller leverages cutting-edge technology to build stronger medical malpractice cases and win bigger settlements for our Indiana clients.
Medical Record Analysis:
Advanced software helps us identify patterns and inconsistencies in digital medical records that might indicate negligence.
Advanced voice-over-IP networks
Enables real-time collaboration between attorneys, medical experts, and investigators, ensuring no detail is overlooked.
Digital Imaging Enhancement:
Our technicians can enhance X-rays, CT scans, and MRIs to reveal evidence that supports your case.
Cloud-based case management
Provides you 24/7 access to your case information and status updates throughout the legal process.
Telemedicine Consultation Platforms:
Allow us to connect with medical experts nationwide for specialized opinions on complex cases.
Service Areas
Indiana Cities We Serve
What Sets Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers Apart
With so many law firms advertising their services, why choose Keller & Keller? The differences are clear.
No Fee Until We Win!
Get Started TodayDon’t Take Our Word For It!
View More Testimonials“Jim Keller and his team are first rate.”
Jenna
Jim went above and beyond to see our case through. Our case manager was knowledgeable and professional and always kept us up-to-date. She collected medical bills and treatment notes and kept flawless records. I was thrilled with the outcome of our settlement and coudn’t be happier with our decision to work with their firm. I highly recommend Keller & Keller to anyone looking for an injury attorney.
Take Action Now
Your Indiana Medical Malpractice Claim Starts Here
Free Consultation
We’ll evaluate your case honestly and explain your options in plain English. We’ll come to you, whether you’re at home, in the hospital, or wherever is convenient.
We Fight
Our experienced team fights to investigate thoroughly, deal with insurance companies, and handle all the legal complexities while you focus on getting better.
You Recover
Focus on healing while we handle the rest. We’ll fight for you like we’d fight for our own family, because that’s exactly how we see you.
Zero Fee Guarantee
We believe everyone deserves quality legal representation, regardless of their financial situation. That’s why we work on a contingency basis. You pay absolutely nothing unless and until we win your case. No upfront costs, no hidden fees, no financial risk to you.
* Clients may owe court costs if they lose
The Keller Tradition:
Three Generations of Fighting for Indiana Families
Frequently Asked Questions
Have questions about your case? We’re here to help.
Injured and not sure what to do next?
We’ll help guide you through everything you need to know